President's DNA Initiative
-
Advancing Justice Through DNA Technology
DNA Analyst Training
previous pagenext page

Summary of Advantages and Disadvantages

Home > DNA Extraction & Quantitation > Quantitation > Data Analysis for Quantitative PCR > Summary of Advantages and Disadvantages

Summary of Method Advantages and Disadvantages

Method

Advantages

Disadvantages

Yield Gel

  • Quality of DNA can be assessed (level of degradation)
  • Carcinogenic chemical (EtBr)
  • Not as sensitive as other methods
  • Uses intercalating dye requiring double-stranded DNA
  • Not human DNA specific
  • Not automatable

Absorption Spectrophotometry

  • Rapid process
  • Quality of DNA can be assessed (level of degradation)
  • Relatively inexpensive
  • Automatable
  • Not human DNA specific

Fluorometry

  • Semi-selective for double-stranded DNA
  • Relatively sensitive for DNA detection
  • Automatable
  • Not human DNA specific
  • Quality of DNA cannot be assessed (level of degradation)

Slot Blot Hybridization

  • Human DNA specific
  • Easy to analyze
  • Not automatable
  • More labor intensive than some other methods
  • Semi-quantitative
  • Quality of DNA cannot be assessed (level of degradation)

AluQuant™

  • Sensitive
  • Automatable
  • Human DNA specific
  • Quality of DNA cannot be assessed

SYBR® Green

  • Sensitive
  • Indications of inhibition 14
  • Less expensive - no requirement for probes

 

  • No commercial kit available
  • Binds to double stranded DNA
  • Must be placed in a dedicated room due to amplified product

Fluorescent resonance energy transfer (FRET)

  • Rapid process
  • Higher precision and accuracy compared to other methods
  • Automatable
  • Human DNA specific
  • Indications of inhibition
  • Sensitive
  • Must be placed in a dedicated room due to amplified product
  • No commercial kit currently available for all methods (molecular beacons)

< Previous Page  ::  Next Page >

Presidents seal logo, DOJ seal logo